2023
Herb, Ulrich
14.02.2023, (Presentation delivered within the session "Risks and Trust in Pursuit of a Well-functioning Persistent Identifier Infrastructure for Research" within the virtual NISO Plus 2023 Conference.).
Abstract | Links | BibTeX | Tags: Diamond Open Access Publishers, Persistent identifier, PID, PID implementation, PID landscape, Publishers, Research funders, Research Funding Organizations, Research Performing Organisations, RFOs, RPOs
@misc{herb_ulrich_2023_7636654,
title = {Risks and Trust in Pursuit of a well-functioning Persistent Identifier Infrastructure for Research - Recommendations and some selected outcomes},
author = { Ulrich Herb},
url = {https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.7636654},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.7636654},
year = {2023},
date = {2023-02-14},
urldate = {2023-02-14},
publisher = {Zenodo},
abstract = {A presentation on the scidecode study on "Risks and Trust in pursuit of a well functioning Persistent Identifier infrastructure", commissioned by Knowledge Exchange (KE). The presentation outlines the methodological approach, some selective findings, and reports some of the recommendations made. These address especially funding organisations, research performing organisations (RPOs) and publishers (with an emphasis on diamond Open Access publishers). The presentation was given on occasion of NISO Plus conference 2023.},
note = {Presentation delivered within the session "Risks and Trust in Pursuit of a Well-functioning Persistent Identifier Infrastructure for Research" within the virtual NISO Plus 2023 Conference.},
keywords = {Diamond Open Access Publishers, Persistent identifier, PID, PID implementation, PID landscape, Publishers, Research funders, Research Funding Organizations, Research Performing Organisations, RFOs, RPOs},
pubstate = {published},
tppubtype = {presentation}
}
A presentation on the scidecode study on "Risks and Trust in pursuit of a well functioning Persistent Identifier infrastructure", commissioned by Knowledge Exchange (KE). The presentation outlines the methodological approach, some selective findings, and reports some of the recommendations made. These address especially funding organisations, research performing organisations (RPOs) and publishers (with an emphasis on diamond Open Access publishers). The presentation was given on occasion of NISO Plus conference 2023.
de Castro, Pablo
The (Currently) Fragmented PID Landscape: An Overview Presentation
14.02.2023, (Presentation delivered within the session "Risks and Trust in Pursuit of a Well-functioning Persistent Identifier Infrastructure for Research" within the virtual NISO Plus 2023 Conference.).
Abstract | Links | BibTeX | Tags: Fragmentation, Persistent identifier, PID, PID implementation, PID landscape
@misc{de_castro_pablo_2023_7551927,
title = {The (Currently) Fragmented PID Landscape: An Overview},
author = {Pablo de Castro},
url = {https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.7551927},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.7551927},
year = {2023},
date = {2023-02-14},
urldate = {2023-02-14},
publisher = {Zenodo},
abstract = {This NISO Plus 2023 talk addresses various issues around the fragmentation of the current persistent identifier landscape as identified in the course of the study on PIDs commissioned by the Knowledge Exchange. The seven case studies produced in the course of this work are presented showing the various types of PIDs addressed in each of them. Three different aspects are then examined under the common theme of PID landscape fragmentation: the dichotomy between 'technical' and 'admin-oriented' PIDs, the coexistence of competing technical solutions for specific PIDs and the ambiguous concept of 'community' in the expression "community-driven PID". Two main recommendations are finally provided to address the current fragmentation in the PID landscape.},
note = {Presentation delivered within the session "Risks and Trust in Pursuit of a Well-functioning Persistent Identifier Infrastructure for Research" within the virtual NISO Plus 2023 Conference.},
keywords = {Fragmentation, Persistent identifier, PID, PID implementation, PID landscape},
pubstate = {published},
tppubtype = {presentation}
}
This NISO Plus 2023 talk addresses various issues around the fragmentation of the current persistent identifier landscape as identified in the course of the study on PIDs commissioned by the Knowledge Exchange. The seven case studies produced in the course of this work are presented showing the various types of PIDs addressed in each of them. Three different aspects are then examined under the common theme of PID landscape fragmentation: the dichotomy between 'technical' and 'admin-oriented' PIDs, the coexistence of competing technical solutions for specific PIDs and the ambiguous concept of 'community' in the expression "community-driven PID". Two main recommendations are finally provided to address the current fragmentation in the PID landscape.
Herb, Ulrich
PIDs - Risiken, problematische Implementierungen, Empfehlungen Presentation
TAPIR-Workshop "TeilAutomatisiertes Persistent-Identifier-basiertes Reporting", 06.02.2023.
Abstract | Links | BibTeX | Tags: Failed PIDs, Fragmentierung, Persistent identifier, PID, PID implementation, PID landscape
@misc{herb_ulrich_2023_7619565,
title = {PIDs - Risiken, problematische Implementierungen, Empfehlungen},
author = { Ulrich Herb},
url = {https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.7619565},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.7619565},
year = {2023},
date = {2023-02-06},
urldate = {2023-02-01},
publisher = {Zenodo},
abstract = {Der Vortrag beschreibt eine von scidecode science consulting im Auftrag von Knowledge Exchange (KE) durchgeführte Studie über Risiken und Vertrauen als (Miss-)Erfolgsfaktoren für die Ausgestaltung einer funktionalen Persistent Identifier (PID) Infrastruktur. Er beleuchtet primär Risiken für die PID Landschaft und präsentiert eine Selektion am Empfehlungen zur Gestaltung des PID Systems, die sich dezidiert an Forschungsförderer und Forschungsorganisationen richten.
Der Vortrag wurde gehalten anlässlich des TAPIR-Workshop "TeilAutomatisiertes Persistent-Identifier-basiertes Reporting" vom 6. Februar 2023. Der Bericht zur Studie "Building the plane as we fly it: the promise of Persistent Identifiers" ist verfügbar unter https://zenodo.org/record/7258286
The presentation describes a study conducted by scidecode science consulting on behalf of Knowledge Exchange (KE) on risks and trust as factors of success or failure for the design of a functional Persistent Identifier (PID) infrastructure. It primarily highlights risks for the PID landscape and presents a selection of recommendations for the development of the PID system, which are aimed specifically at research funders and research organisations.
The presentation was given at the TAPIR workshop "Partially Automated Persistent Identifier-based Reporting" on 6 February 2023. The report on the study ""Building the plane as we fly it: the promise of Persistent Identifiers" is available at https://zenodo.org/record/7258286},
howpublished = {TAPIR-Workshop "TeilAutomatisiertes Persistent-Identifier-basiertes Reporting"},
keywords = {Failed PIDs, Fragmentierung, Persistent identifier, PID, PID implementation, PID landscape},
pubstate = {published},
tppubtype = {presentation}
}
Der Vortrag beschreibt eine von scidecode science consulting im Auftrag von Knowledge Exchange (KE) durchgeführte Studie über Risiken und Vertrauen als (Miss-)Erfolgsfaktoren für die Ausgestaltung einer funktionalen Persistent Identifier (PID) Infrastruktur. Er beleuchtet primär Risiken für die PID Landschaft und präsentiert eine Selektion am Empfehlungen zur Gestaltung des PID Systems, die sich dezidiert an Forschungsförderer und Forschungsorganisationen richten.
Der Vortrag wurde gehalten anlässlich des TAPIR-Workshop "TeilAutomatisiertes Persistent-Identifier-basiertes Reporting" vom 6. Februar 2023. Der Bericht zur Studie "Building the plane as we fly it: the promise of Persistent Identifiers" ist verfügbar unter https://zenodo.org/record/7258286
The presentation describes a study conducted by scidecode science consulting on behalf of Knowledge Exchange (KE) on risks and trust as factors of success or failure for the design of a functional Persistent Identifier (PID) infrastructure. It primarily highlights risks for the PID landscape and presents a selection of recommendations for the development of the PID system, which are aimed specifically at research funders and research organisations.
The presentation was given at the TAPIR workshop "Partially Automated Persistent Identifier-based Reporting" on 6 February 2023. The report on the study ""Building the plane as we fly it: the promise of Persistent Identifiers" is available at https://zenodo.org/record/7258286
Der Vortrag wurde gehalten anlässlich des TAPIR-Workshop "TeilAutomatisiertes Persistent-Identifier-basiertes Reporting" vom 6. Februar 2023. Der Bericht zur Studie "Building the plane as we fly it: the promise of Persistent Identifiers" ist verfügbar unter https://zenodo.org/record/7258286
The presentation describes a study conducted by scidecode science consulting on behalf of Knowledge Exchange (KE) on risks and trust as factors of success or failure for the design of a functional Persistent Identifier (PID) infrastructure. It primarily highlights risks for the PID landscape and presents a selection of recommendations for the development of the PID system, which are aimed specifically at research funders and research organisations.
The presentation was given at the TAPIR workshop "Partially Automated Persistent Identifier-based Reporting" on 6 February 2023. The report on the study ""Building the plane as we fly it: the promise of Persistent Identifiers" is available at https://zenodo.org/record/7258286
de Castro, Pablo; Herb, Ulrich; Rothfritz, Laura; Schöpfel, Joachim
Building the plane as we fly it: the promise of Persistent Identifiers Technical Report
Knowledge Exchange 2023.
Abstract | Links | BibTeX | Tags: Persistent identifier, PID, PID implementation, PID landscape, Report
@techreport{de_castro_pablo_2023_7258286,
title = {Building the plane as we fly it: the promise of Persistent Identifiers},
author = { Pablo de Castro and Ulrich Herb and Laura Rothfritz and Joachim Schöpfel},
url = {https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.7258286},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.7258286},
year = {2023},
date = {2023-02-02},
urldate = {2023-02-01},
publisher = {Zenodo},
institution = {Knowledge Exchange},
abstract = {This report is the main outcome of a study commissioned by Knowledge Exchange (KE). The study was aimed at investigating “Risks and trust in pursuit of a well functioning Persistent Identifier infrastructure for research”. The investigation set out to analyse the current state of the Persistent Identifier (PID) landscape in the six Knowledge Exchange partner countries and beyond, taking emerging PIDs particularly into account and examining the roles of relevant stakeholders as PID service providers, higher education institutions, researchers, publishers and national libraries.
The report examines the PID landscape and provides a detailed look at what can go wrong with an unreliable PID service. In addition, a series of recommendations aimed at each stakeholder group are presented.
Seven complementary case studies accompany the report, helping provide a deeper insight into specific areas of activity, workflows and stakeholders within this wider PID landscape. Each can be accessed through the report.},
keywords = {Persistent identifier, PID, PID implementation, PID landscape, Report},
pubstate = {published},
tppubtype = {techreport}
}
This report is the main outcome of a study commissioned by Knowledge Exchange (KE). The study was aimed at investigating “Risks and trust in pursuit of a well functioning Persistent Identifier infrastructure for research”. The investigation set out to analyse the current state of the Persistent Identifier (PID) landscape in the six Knowledge Exchange partner countries and beyond, taking emerging PIDs particularly into account and examining the roles of relevant stakeholders as PID service providers, higher education institutions, researchers, publishers and national libraries.
The report examines the PID landscape and provides a detailed look at what can go wrong with an unreliable PID service. In addition, a series of recommendations aimed at each stakeholder group are presented.
Seven complementary case studies accompany the report, helping provide a deeper insight into specific areas of activity, workflows and stakeholders within this wider PID landscape. Each can be accessed through the report.
The report examines the PID landscape and provides a detailed look at what can go wrong with an unreliable PID service. In addition, a series of recommendations aimed at each stakeholder group are presented.
Seven complementary case studies accompany the report, helping provide a deeper insight into specific areas of activity, workflows and stakeholders within this wider PID landscape. Each can be accessed through the report.
de Castro, Pablo; Herb, Ulrich; Rothfritz, Laura; Schöpfel, Joachim
Failed PIDs and unreliable PID implementations Technical Manual
Knowledge Exchange 2023.
Abstract | Links | BibTeX | Tags: Case Study, Failed PIDs, Persistent Identifier, PID, PID implementation, PID landscape
@manual{pablo_de_castro_2023_7330527,
title = {Failed PIDs and unreliable PID implementations},
author = {Pablo de Castro and Ulrich Herb and Laura Rothfritz and Joachim Schöpfel},
url = {https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.7330527},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.7330527},
year = {2023},
date = {2023-02-01},
urldate = {2023-02-01},
publisher = {Zenodo},
organization = {Knowledge Exchange},
abstract = {This case study is part of a series that has been produced within the study on “Risks and Trust in pursuit of a well-functioning PID infrastructure for research” commissioned by the Knowledge Exchange in July 2021. The main outcome of this work is a report examining the current PID landscape with an emphasis on its risks and trust-related issues.
The case study explores what happens if organizations providing and managing PIDs are unreliable. It examines issues around risk and trust, the importance of a committed organization and contingency plans.
The report, Building the Plane as We Fly It: the Promise of Persistent Identifiers, and remaining complementary case studies have also been published.},
keywords = {Case Study, Failed PIDs, Persistent Identifier, PID, PID implementation, PID landscape},
pubstate = {published},
tppubtype = {manual}
}
This case study is part of a series that has been produced within the study on “Risks and Trust in pursuit of a well-functioning PID infrastructure for research” commissioned by the Knowledge Exchange in July 2021. The main outcome of this work is a report examining the current PID landscape with an emphasis on its risks and trust-related issues.
The case study explores what happens if organizations providing and managing PIDs are unreliable. It examines issues around risk and trust, the importance of a committed organization and contingency plans.
The report, Building the Plane as We Fly It: the Promise of Persistent Identifiers, and remaining complementary case studies have also been published.
The case study explores what happens if organizations providing and managing PIDs are unreliable. It examines issues around risk and trust, the importance of a committed organization and contingency plans.
The report, Building the Plane as We Fly It: the Promise of Persistent Identifiers, and remaining complementary case studies have also been published.
de Castro, Pablo; Herb, Ulrich; Rothfritz, Laura; Schöpfel, Joachim
Persistent identifiers for research instruments and facilities: an emerging PID domain in need of coordination Technical Manual
Knowledge Exchange 2023.
Abstract | Links | BibTeX | Tags: Case Study, Conferences, ConfID, Facilities, PID, PID implementation, PID landscape, Research Instruments
@manual{pablo_de_castro_2023_7330372,
title = {Persistent identifiers for research instruments and facilities: an emerging PID domain in need of coordination},
author = {Pablo de Castro and Ulrich Herb and Laura Rothfritz and Joachim Schöpfel},
url = {https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.7330372},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.7330372},
year = {2023},
date = {2023-02-01},
urldate = {2023-02-01},
publisher = {Zenodo},
organization = {Knowledge Exchange},
abstract = {This case study is part of a series that has been produced within the study on “Risks and Trust in pursuit of a well-functioning PID infrastructure for research” commissioned by the Knowledge Exchange in July 2021. The main outcome of this work is a report examining the current PID landscape with an emphasis on its risks and trust-related issues.
The case study aims to explore the challenges faced and the opportunities offered by the gradual implementation of emerging PIDs. The main focus of this case study is on persistent identifiers for research instruments and facilities but the analysis addresses emerging PID infrastructure and therefore has links to other PID areas like persistent identifiers for conferences (ConfIDs) and – to a certain extent – to PIDs addressed in other case studies such as IGSNs for samples and ROR IDs for organisational identifiers.
The report, Building the Plane as We Fly It: the Promise of Persistent Identifiers, and remaining complementary case studies have also been published.},
keywords = {Case Study, Conferences, ConfID, Facilities, PID, PID implementation, PID landscape, Research Instruments},
pubstate = {published},
tppubtype = {manual}
}
This case study is part of a series that has been produced within the study on “Risks and Trust in pursuit of a well-functioning PID infrastructure for research” commissioned by the Knowledge Exchange in July 2021. The main outcome of this work is a report examining the current PID landscape with an emphasis on its risks and trust-related issues.
The case study aims to explore the challenges faced and the opportunities offered by the gradual implementation of emerging PIDs. The main focus of this case study is on persistent identifiers for research instruments and facilities but the analysis addresses emerging PID infrastructure and therefore has links to other PID areas like persistent identifiers for conferences (ConfIDs) and – to a certain extent – to PIDs addressed in other case studies such as IGSNs for samples and ROR IDs for organisational identifiers.
The report, Building the Plane as We Fly It: the Promise of Persistent Identifiers, and remaining complementary case studies have also been published.
The case study aims to explore the challenges faced and the opportunities offered by the gradual implementation of emerging PIDs. The main focus of this case study is on persistent identifiers for research instruments and facilities but the analysis addresses emerging PID infrastructure and therefore has links to other PID areas like persistent identifiers for conferences (ConfIDs) and – to a certain extent – to PIDs addressed in other case studies such as IGSNs for samples and ROR IDs for organisational identifiers.
The report, Building the Plane as We Fly It: the Promise of Persistent Identifiers, and remaining complementary case studies have also been published.
de Castro, Pablo; Herb, Ulrich; Rothfritz, Laura; Schöpfel, Joachim
The gradual implementation of organisational identifiers (OrgIDs) Technical Manual
Knowledge Exchange 2023.
Abstract | Links | BibTeX | Tags: Case Study, Organisational Identifiers, OrgIDs, Persistent identifier, PID, PID implementation, PID landscape, Ringgold, ROR
@manual{pablo_de_castro_2023_7327535,
title = {The gradual implementation of organisational identifiers (OrgIDs)},
author = {Pablo de Castro and Ulrich Herb and Laura Rothfritz and Joachim Schöpfel},
url = {https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.7327535},
doi = {10.5281/zenodo.7327535},
year = {2023},
date = {2023-02-01},
urldate = {2023-02-01},
publisher = {Zenodo},
organization = {Knowledge Exchange},
abstract = {This case study is part of a series that has been produced within the study on “Risks and Trust in pursuit of a well-functioning PID infrastructure for research” commissioned by the Knowledge Exchange in July 2021. The main outcome of this work is a report examining the current PID landscape with an emphasis on its risks and trust-related issues.
This case study provides insight into the process that led to selecting the Research Organization Registry (ROR) – initially based on the Digital Science Global Research Identifier (GRID) database – as the default international framework for the provision of OrgIDs. Insight into the challenges triggered by current developments are also addressed.
The report, Building the Plane as We Fly It: the Promise of Persistent Identifiers, and remaining complementary case studies have also been published.},
keywords = {Case Study, Organisational Identifiers, OrgIDs, Persistent identifier, PID, PID implementation, PID landscape, Ringgold, ROR},
pubstate = {published},
tppubtype = {manual}
}
This case study is part of a series that has been produced within the study on “Risks and Trust in pursuit of a well-functioning PID infrastructure for research” commissioned by the Knowledge Exchange in July 2021. The main outcome of this work is a report examining the current PID landscape with an emphasis on its risks and trust-related issues.
This case study provides insight into the process that led to selecting the Research Organization Registry (ROR) – initially based on the Digital Science Global Research Identifier (GRID) database – as the default international framework for the provision of OrgIDs. Insight into the challenges triggered by current developments are also addressed.
The report, Building the Plane as We Fly It: the Promise of Persistent Identifiers, and remaining complementary case studies have also been published.
This case study provides insight into the process that led to selecting the Research Organization Registry (ROR) – initially based on the Digital Science Global Research Identifier (GRID) database – as the default international framework for the provision of OrgIDs. Insight into the challenges triggered by current developments are also addressed.
The report, Building the Plane as We Fly It: the Promise of Persistent Identifiers, and remaining complementary case studies have also been published.